Tag Archives: rethinking college

Over Consuming College in an Over Consuming Society?

My son Eric sent me a link to a May 15 New York Times piece by Jacques Steinberg, “Plan B: Skip College”, where the author challenges, or at least questions, the idea that the best path forward for all high school graduates is to go to four-year college. Steinberg cites statistics that only half of those who began a four-year bachelor’s degree program in the fall of 2006 will get that degree within six years, according to the latest projections from the Department of Education. It made me wonder that in a society where people are prone to over consume those items deemed by advertising and cultural norms to be “needs”, we may be over consuming college as well.

(See a lot of discussion of this piece on DailyKOS.)

Continue reading →

College… The New High School… Following Up

Besides posting my blog entries here on my very own blog, I also post them on Daily KOS, a progressive political blog site. What is great about Daily KOS is that I get a great deal of responses to my posts which is always great when you are writing and also exposes me to other wisdom that expands my own thinking.

I got over 200 comments to my Daily KOS post yesterday on “College… The New High School” (though many were responses to other responses and not to my original post.) If you want to see my “diary” on Daily KOS, including all the responses I get, click here.

Here are bits from some of the many great heartfelt and provocative comments. I am taking the liberty to excerpt several of them (hopefully not too badly out of context) and comment further to try and keep this discussion stoked. Continue reading →

College… The New High School?

I’ve seen a position put forward by people in the Obama administration and others attempting to anticipate the future of education in America that, just as 30 years ago it was important that all youth graduated from high school to find a reasonably good job, today it is equally important that all youth graduate from some sort of two or four year college program to achieve a similar work readiness in today’s world.

On the one hand, since more and more jobs seem to require computer and other technical skills, and society in general seems to be getting more complex, it seems pretty obvious there is truth to this position. Like it or not… everyone now needs fourteen to sixteen years of mandatory education. If you throw in kindergarten, which is pretty universally attended these days, we are talking about fifteen to seventeen years. And what about pre-school, and all the efforts around the country to make available (or even require) universal pre-school attendance for all kids prior to kindergarten? Let’s tack on another year to that requirement. Continue reading →